Borussia Dortmund presently top their Champions League group with a flawless 100% record. Two games, two wins, 10 goals scored and just one conceded-it's safe to say the German team has every reason to be confident. However, one interesting move did raise eyebrows as the team decided against training at Santiago Bernabéu ahead of facing Real Madrid. Why? Out of fear of spying.
Follow Playing for 90 on X (Twitter).
This unusual decision raises an intriguing question. To what extent is the fear of leaking tactical secrets part of preparation for any team? The coach of Dortmund, Nuri Sahin, dismissed this as the official reason for the fear of espionage. But in the competitive environment when technology is being increasingly integrated into sports, it is not hard to imagine such concerns crossing the minds of many coaches.
Real Fear or Management Strategy?
What is really amazing is that the final training in the match arena was skipped, while this broke the common tradition in soccer: teams usually visit the opponent's stadium one day in advance to get acquainted with the atmosphere and test the field-even doing some play rehearsals. But Dortmund chose another path.
The first to guess the motive of such a decision was the German newspaper "Bild". According to their information, Sahin kept the team in the controlled environment of Dortmund because of tactical espionage concerns. To be quite frank, at times when data analysis is used, flying drones over training sessions, and detailed footage of opponents, this is not such a far-fetched concern.
Sahin, however, downplayed the matter at a news conference and explained that the reason behind training in Germany was out of consideration to the squad's physical condition. He said Borussia Dortmund is facing an exhausting run of away games, and allowing players to stay in a setting they are familiar with before embarking on a stretch filled with travel seemed the most sensible thing to do.
And it does make sense. In the days that follow, other than the Champions League home match against Real Madrid, Dortmund will travel to Augsburg in the Bundesliga before making the trip to Wolfsburg in the DFB-Pokal. Logistically speaking, time-saving, not traveling any more than they have to, could be a major factor in preparing the team.
Carlo Ancelotti: "No Secrets in Soccer Anymore"
On the other hand, Real Madrid's coach Carlo Ancelotti did not beat around the bush when asked about the possibility of spying at the Bernabéu. For him, the concern seemed somewhat overblown, especially in today's soccer landscape. "Nowadays, you know everything about your opponent," Ancelotti said. And frankly, he is right.
With all the information teams have about another team, it is tough to maintain a tactical secret. Every move, every tweak in a formation or set-piece play is due to have been properly dissected by analysts and opposing coaches. In this big data age, old-school espionage seems rather outdated.
But Ancelotti's comment carries more reflection in it: With everything in one's hands, has the surprise factor disappeared from modern soccer? Maybe the paranoia of espionage leads coaches to drop that psychological and strategic weapon that sometimes makes all the difference in a decisive match?
Spying: Old Foe in Soccer
It is on record that soccer has equally experienced its share of espionage scandals. In 2019, the then Leeds United boss Marcelo Bielsa accepted spying on training sessions belonging to Derby County ahead of their Championship match. The code was heavily criticized by the public but maintained that such a practice is encompassed in the in-depth analysis that he demands of his teams. The Canadian women's soccer team was also sanctioned for spying during the Paris 2024 Olympics.
There has always been espionage in soccer, either directly or through subtle analyses. But with today's technology, that line gets blurred between what's acceptable and what's unethical. Most cases still depend on execution on the field. Knowing your opponent may give you intelligence, but knowing how to use that is really the game-changer in almost every case.