Tottenham proves to be Manchester City’s kryptonite

Spurs outclass City once again as James Maddison shines in a game to remember

Manchester City FC v Tottenham Hotspur FC - Premier League
Manchester City FC v Tottenham Hotspur FC - Premier League | Visionhaus/GettyImages

Tottenham Hotspur, on Saturday, reaffirmed its tag as the team that always gives Manchester City a run for their money. Playing at the Etihad Stadium, Ange Postecoglou's squad turned on a clinical performance, thrashing the reigning four-time Premier League champions 4-0.

Follow Playing for 90 on X (Twitter).

While City dominated possession, Spurs showed that soccer is about moments. And it was the moments capitalized on by James Maddison, Pedro Porro, and Brennan Johnson that defined the game. The result not only marked Manchester City's heaviest home defeat since 2003 but also extended Pep Guardiola's losing streak to five matches, an unprecedented run in his managerial career.

Tottenham: City's Achilles' Heel

No doubt, everybody knows that Tottenham was always one of the biggest headaches for Manchester City. In recent seasons, Spurs stole crucial wins, secured draws in thrilling games, and now chalked another remarkable chapter into this rivalry.

But Saturday's dominant victory was an even bigger body blow after last season's dramatic 3-3 draw that frustrated City. With an impeccable counterattacking strategy, Tottenham methodically exposed the defensive lapses of City-a testament to the tactical discipline of Postecoglou and his team.

"City tests you in every aspect of the game. They make you defend, work hard and play soccer. Today, we responded on all fronts," he said after the game.

Brilliance of Maddison

James Maddison was undeniably the star of the night. The midfielder, on his birthday, dictated Tottenham's offense and scored two goals in just 20 minutes. First, after breaching the defense to finish a cross from Dejan Kulusevski, then after intercepting a misplaced pass from Josko Gvardiol, exchanging quick passes with Son Heung-min, and classy chip over Ederson.

Beyond the goals, though, was Maddison's intelligence to exploit gaps in City's midfield. His performance wasn't just technical; it was cerebral, as Postecoglou reflected. "Maddison had two weeks of hard work with us. He was ready for a big game, and tonight he showed why he's so vital to our team."

Tottenham's Counterattack Masterclass

While Maddison set the tone early, the third and fourth put the seal on a near-perfect display. Pedro Porro, a former City player, extended the lead with a precise strike set up by Solanke. In stoppage time, Timo Werner sprinted past Kyle Walker and set up Brennan Johnson, who coolly slotted home to complete the rout.

And Postecoglou's approach was remarkably simple: use City's intense man-to-man defense to his advantage by finding space for his wide players. "We knew we'd have to defend a lot, but we also knew City loves to mark tightly. We used that to our advantage and found the spaces to punish them," explained the manager.

A Win to Remember

It was a historic victory-not just because of the scoreline but because of what it meant for both teams. The victory was a loud statement by Tottenham that they could compete at the highest level, which seemed to contrast with the disappointing display against Ipswich Town in the previous round.

Today, we showed we're progressing as a team. It's a big moment for everyone at the club, but the challenge now is going to be maintaining this level," Postecoglou summarized.

At the same time, Manchester City has much to consider. The defeat laid bare some weaknesses that Guardiola will have to sort out sharpish if his team is to get their season up and running.

For Tottenham, this was much more than a win-it was a statement of intent. For City, it was a rude awakening.